Executive Interviews: Interview with Kamal Singh on Women Executives
July 2007
-
By Dr. Nagendra V Chowdary
Kamal Singh working with the British Council as Head, Governance & Social Justice, India.
-
Despite significant gains, women
still make up only 10% of senior
managers in Fortune 500 companies,
less that 4% of the uppermost ranks
of CEO, President, Executive Vice
President, and COO; and less than
3% of top corporate earners. Why
does it happen? What are the
possible reasons? We all know the syndrome of the
"glass ceiling" which exists for
women. I have an interesting
experience from an Indian public
sector: in a gender career profiling
exercise it was analyzed that women were not being considered for
boardroom appointments as during
their early working lives they
|
|
had
not done field assignments and
therefore were seen to lack the
required field experience. It was
further analyzed that such field
assignments were generally on offer
when women had responsibilities
for early childhood care and without
a robust support system they were
unable to leave their small children
to go to the field. Once this was
recognized, the organization not
only provided counseling for
younger women to ensure
completion of their field
assignments within a certain period
of their career, but also improved on
child care and other facilities to
encourage women to take up diverse
opportunities. We need more
research-led strategies for making
improvements. -
Women today have more
opportunities than ever, to pursue
desired life goals. Yet, we see many
of them walking away from their
dreams. When women enter the
professional arena or start families,
they are often forced to see that
"ambition and passion for
recognition" is unwomanly. Do
women lack ambition? (Many also
associate ambition with egotism or
selfishness) How can women
become ambitious about ambition
including cultivating connections
with people, who have the power to
advance their work and publicly
praise their successes? In one sales company the "killer
instinct" was being promoted to
increase sales, which was against my
personal ethos and life philosophy!
So, if women wish to make certain
choices in life then so be it. In UK,
there is limited childcare available,
hence some women may choose to
time off fromtheir careers to bring up
their children when they choose to
return to work there may be
"refresher" and "update"
opportunities available to enable
them to reintegrate with the
workforce more easily. In India a
career break is seen as disastrous!
One needs to analyze gender
differentials and create opportunities
that would promote diversity in the
workforce for women, men, people
with disability etc. I think we also
need to debate the difference
between ambition and achievement,
just as we now systematically debate
the difference between aggressive
behavior and assertive behavior. On
your point about "cultivating
connections" I think, again, it's the
public/private dichotomy ofwomen's
lives along with their multiple roles
in household management. The "old
boys network" is strong on
socializing in the evening hours or
over drinks womenmay or may not
wish to do so. Networking
opportunities through trade and
other associations also may be
limited for women, due to timings or locations. Further, sometimes their
passion for achievement is crushed
due to power relations within the
household, where their success is
seen as threatening and women then
feel the need for compromising with
their careers for the sake of peace at
home. We are a democratic country
but do not practice democratic
behavior within our institutions,
such as homes and offices! As girls move from adolescence to
womanhood, should they give up on
ambition? For appearing more
womanly, should they suppress
their ambitiousness, cede
recognition to men and abandon
their dreams? Torn between their
personal and professional pulls,
many appear to quit their jobs. I think this is a gender stereotypical
loaded question! My work in the
British Council has focused on
tapping women's potential, create
opportunities for their growth and
give them the confidence to take
more responsibility for their own
lives. School dropouts analysis has
shown that girls are withdrawn from
school to take care of siblings and
household tasks. Workforce
dropouts analysis shows women
choose to take on childcare and
household responsibility. It's a loss
for the industry that trained and
talented women are not able to get
back to work after a gap we need to
create flexible working options. What's the role of the family
members and relatives in preparing
women for greater responsibilities?
Who should anchor the role of a
cheerleader, a mentor and a coach? Let me give an example from our
work with elected women
councilors in Punjab. A large
majority told us that they contested
the elections as the opportunity
came up after the 74th Constitutional Amendment which provided 33%
reservation for women in politics at
the local council level. Their
families were most supportive in the
lead-up to the elections, helped with
the campaign and rallies. However,
after they were elected and were
required to go to the council
regularly to attend meetings and
take on their duties, their families
did not want to support them any
more! Why was that, we asked?
They told us that family members
felt council work was taking too
much time, and the women were not
spending sufficient time on their
household tasks, they were
neglecting their family duties! These
elected women were in a dilemma!
Through our training program they
were able to enhance their skills in
time management, resource
management, being assertive and
improve their work-life balance.
Mentors and coaches are important
people in our lives who can be from
within the family or amongst
friends, peers or senior colleagues
male or female. They can help
validate views, encourage and
support at the right time. Mentoring
helps develop leadership,
management and business skills.
Another technique we use in the
British Council is "shadowing"
where you are attached to a senior
colleague to experience the
processes of decision-making,
policy review and boardroom
meetings. Feedback is that it is an
excellent learning experience.
1.
Women's Western Wear Market Case Study
2. ICMR
Case Collection
3.
Case Study Volumes
|